1857 The Church was founded.
1859 The Methodist Episcopal Church was dedicated at its location on Merrick Road, Atlanticville.
1915 The Church became the Seaford Church when Atlanticville was renamed Seaford.
1923 The Church was physically moved from its site on Merrick Road to its present location at the corner of Washington and Waverly Avenues.
1958 Ground broken for new Education Building, under Pastor Garfield Thompson.
1967 Corner stone laid for new sanctuary, under Pastor Craig Haight.
1968 Bishop Lloyd C. Wicke consecrates new facilities.
1970 David Ver Nooy - Pastor.
1977 Pastor, Dr. Richard F. Williamson arrives.
2009 Dr. Richard F. Williamson retires after 32 years
2009 Reverend Dr. Edwin Jones named new Pastor of Seaford United Methodist Church
2013 Reverend Steven M. Knutsen named new Pastor of Seaford United Methodist Church
2020 Pastor Wayne Redman named new Pastor of Seaford United Methodist Church
2022 Pastor Paul Smith named new Pastor of Seaford United Methodist Church